When a different customer buys
A different customer buying from you raises a question. It does not, by itself, prove that the brand is poorly positioned: it may reveal an opportunity, a mistaken assumption or an incoherence between product, price and channel.
What to examine
Who buys, which product families they choose, what they pay and where they find the brand. Also, who shows interest but does not buy, and what evidence helps explain why.
Compare this with the customer the offer serves, not just the profile described in a presentation.
The decision at stake
Before changing the campaign, establish whether the offer still serves the intended customer. Assortment, availability, price and the retail setting may be attracting someone else.
The response may be to adjust those decisions or review positioning if the demand you have found makes sense for the identity and the business. Expanding your audience requires an explicit decision.
How to assess progress
Define the behaviour you expect to see and track it by product and channel: purchase, repeat purchase, actual selling price and response to the offer.
The criterion is whether decisions build the chosen positioning, without mistaking a single campaign for an established change.